Ranking the Rankers – 10 June 2023

The unofficial official schoolboy rugby rankings of South Africa for the week ending 10 June 2023.

# SCHOOL R B S N TTL
1 Grey College 1 1 1 1 4
2 Paarl Gim 2 2 2 2 8
3 Garsfontein 3 3 3 3 12
4 Paul Roos Gym 4 4 4 5 17
5 Outeniqua 8 5 7 4 24
6 Paarl Boys High 6 8 5 6 25
7 Hilton College 5 6 12 7 30
8 Affies 7 13 6 9 35
9 Boland Landbou 9 7 16 8 40
10 Michaelhouse 12 9 14 12 47
11 DHS 19 10 11 11 51
12 EG Jansen 10 19 15 10 54
13 KES 15 21 8 15 59
14 Monnas 14 22 10 16 62
15 Jeppe 16 12 13 22 63
15 Rondebosch 18 14 17 14 63
17 Waterkloof 17 11 26 13 67
18 Wynberg BH 21 15 9 23 68
19 Bishops 11 17 24 21 73
20 Maritzburg College 13 26 18 19 76
21 Noordheuwel 26 18 23 20 87
22 Stellenberg 22 20 20 28 90
23 Oakdale 20 34 19 27 100
24 Helpmekaar 25 27 21 29 102
25 Welkom Gim 27 16 31 30 104
26 Queens College 28 25 22 31 106
27 Glenwood 24 31 27 26 108
28 Durbanville 29 23 25 32 109
28 Grey High School 23 33 29 24 109
30 Marlow 32 35 30 17 114
31 St Andrews Coll 30 28 38 25 121
32 Kingswood 34 37 37 18 126
33 Pretoria BH 31 43 32 34 140
34 Kearnsney Coll 42 36 28 37 143
35 Westville 35 40 35 36 146
36 Selborne Coll 36 44 36 35 151
37 Graeme Coll 40 46 41 42 169
38 Drostdy HTS 38 50 46 38 172
39 Northwood 33 33 33 99
40 Rustenburg 45 30 41 116
41 Secunda 39 42 40 121
42 Heidelberg Volkies 46 32 49 127
43 SACS 41 39 47 127
44 Eldoraigne 47 38 48 133
45 Menlopark 48 47 39 134
46 Fichardtpark 24 49 73
47 Oos Moot 37 43 80
48 Framesby 43 45 88
49 Pietersburg 41 50 91
50 Marais Viljoen 50 42 92
51 Midstream 43 50 93
52 Transvalia 49 45 94
53 Pearson 48 46 94

33 Comments

  1. avatar
    #33 BlouLou

    @OudAffie: ek weet nie hoe mense ounte kry op n rating sisteem as jy verloor nie. Met n naby verloor verloor mens minder punte en met n groot vwrloor moet mens meer punte verloor. (Elo based). Ek weet nie of elke span elke jaar op o (nul) begin en dan punte opbou en of daar net vanaf die vorige jaar se punte aangegaan word nie? Daaibspelers is reeds weg (75% van hulle) en n klomp o.16’s skuif op. Word daar gekyk na die o.16 rankings dan of net die vorige jaar se 1ste span? Either way is my gevoel dat Affies en stellenberg bv te hoog sit en dat self Kloof te hoog is. Die Monnas game sal bevestig of ons daar hoort.

    ReplyReply
    19 June, 2023 at 13:47
  2. avatar
    #32 OudAffie

    @BlouLou: Probably playing better teams???, yes Affies lost 5, but to the top 5 in the Country for 2023 with only Grey being a blowout. I am not sure but I will put my money on that being the reason.

    ReplyReply
    18 June, 2023 at 17:29
  3. avatar
    #31 Smallies

    @Deon: ek het nou n amandel mielie pit ,n wit degie en n FX floatie gekry waaraan jy byt …..😂😂😂😂😂

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 17:40
  4. avatar
    #30 Kaya 85

    @Deon: just re: your belief that EGJ would move “up” because of their depth…alas no. Their u16 were decisively beaten by Menlo. And their 1st (and 2nd) team has at least as many Boland imports as a number of other NV Cup teams, if not more. I made a special plan to get out to Boksburg last week to watch Jansen, believe me, they can win NV Cup…that’s me on the stream, 1st half far side of the field on R…

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 10:51
  5. avatar
    #29 Deon

    @Smallies: Ja ek sien die Oos-Kaap of dele daarvan bly baie droog. Ek dink nie vloede was al ooit op Stellenbosch so erg soos hierdie een nie. Nog nooit het Noordwal Straat op Stellenbosch verander in ‘n genuine rivier wat boonop sterk loop nie. Ek het in daardie straat groot geword en onthou net een soortgelyke geval êrens in die 70s en dit was nie naby hietrdie een nie.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 09:57
  6. avatar
    #28 Deon

    @Smallies: Hey, dit is glad nie waaroor dit gaan nie. Geensins nie, ek is maar net n brutaal realistiese ou wat lief is om dinge te meet. Ek het geen probleem om te verloor nie, veral nie teen die GCB’s van die wêreld nie. Boonop is ek al gewoond daaraan om te verloor teen hulle. Verder, GCB sit ons glad nie ore aan nie. Hulle eerstespan rugby doen, amper altyd, of A-spanne, en die B span wat se naam met ‘n C begin en D span wat met n P begin, dink ek (Peaches of so iets) :lol: :lol: :lol: Wat die res, skool as geheel betref, baie belangriker aspekte as eerstespan rugby, is dit EENWEG verkeer ten gunste van PRG en verskeie ander skole. Van holrug gery, jaloesie en nyd gepraat, wat is meer holrug gery en gebaseer op geskiedkundige inkorrektheid en chronologiese verdwaaldheid as die aanhoudende geteem, gekyf, geween en gekners van tande oor die Wynland wat onder die WP resorteer sedert 1881 rond, lank voor Cravenweek en voor die WP Boland begin het in 1939??? Dis moeilik om te glo dat daar steeds oor gepraat word. Sommer met persoonlike beledigings ook bygevoeg, wat glad nie pla as dit toepaslik is nie, maar waarvan ek die motief nie verstaan nie.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 09:53
  7. avatar
    #27 Asterix

    @Vleis: Cornwall u/13 have a nr 4 player this year who I believe would have had a very good change of making the bulls craven week team, but I was told he didnt go to the trials as he is also playing cricket and the school is going on a overseas tour at the same time as the craven week.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 09:13
  8. avatar
    #26 Smallies

    @Deon: moenie kla oor n nat kaap nie ,daar is n moerse sterk El Nino stelsel aan die ontwikkel ,swaar tye is op pad

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 05:57
  9. avatar
    #25 Smallies

    @Deon: dis darem vir jou n bitter pil om te sluk die dat n klomp plaas ballasse van die Vrystaat die ongelooflike PRG wat BTW jonger as Grey is so kan ore aan sit….

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 05:53
  10. avatar
    #24 Deon

    @Smallies: Môre Smallies. Ek hoop dit gaan goed. Terug in die natste Wes-Kaap wat ek nog beleef het. Die waarheid kan nooit holrug gery word nie. Daar is darem seker nie fout daarmee om benaminge reg te kry nie? Of hoe? Stabiliteit, stabilis????

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 05:45
  11. avatar
    #23 Smallies

    @Deon: ken jy daardie gesegde ,om n perd holrug te ry …..dis wat jy besig is om te doen.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 05:38
  12. avatar
    #22 Deon

    These are not schoolboy rugby rankings, but schoolboy rugby first team rankings.To most by far the most important ranking, but “schoolboy rugby ranking” is a misnomer for this statistic. Schoolboy rugby rankings would look very different as it would impute the rugby depth of the school . Grey would fall down to I guess 6 or 7. Garsfontein, Hilton and Michaelhouse will probably be below 30. EG Jansen, Monnas etc would move up quite dramatically, and Affies too. That is the problem with schools like the private schools, where very few first team players’ parents can actually afford paying R 30 000 per month for what no-one can explain, 12 months per year, and thus the school’s first team rugby status is actually purchased, but further down much less is happening. So we should call this a first team ranking only.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 05:26
  13. avatar
    #21 Vleis

    @Asterix: Cornwall’s u13 cricket team was in the top 5 of the country in 2011. Two or three are now pro cricketers; however, they lost 10 of the 11 to Boys High and St Alban’s the next year.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 03:02
  14. avatar
    #20 Vleis

    @Asterix: I guess it depends on the strategy of the board of the school. Do they want the school to grow and compete with the larger monastic private schools, or remain a small niche school with the odd good year. Remember that schools like St Stithians, Bennies and St Albans were quite small until some 30 years ago.

    I was on the board of a small private school seven years ago. I recommended that they merge with another new small private school (but with a lot of potential) but it was rejected by the majority of the board…so I understand the dilemma.

    ReplyReply
    16 June, 2023 at 02:56
  15. avatar
    #19 Asterix

    @Kaya 85: Cornwall hill primary doing well in the rugby but high school loses a lot of pupils to the other major schools. Cricket excellent at Cornwall but not the strongest in the rugby, I do however understand they are looking into changing that a bit and have made some plans.

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 23:08
  16. avatar
    #18 Asterix

    @Vleis: Dont think they have a choice they need to be promoted, and I am not sure about the juniors but believe this year will be the best oppertunity to move into the 4th div of the A division. They dont really have the numbers to be competitive against the major schools on all levels. They have excellent coaches and a lot of money but the pupils is more the kids that stay in the estate. It is an excellent school however and really performing well in all theire sport and atop academics school.

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 23:05
  17. avatar
    #17 Asterix

    @Kaya 85: Where the highschool is situated in the estates it is more centurion for me, the second new primary school “ridge” in the estates would for me be close to Ekurhleni, it is a very big estate.

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 22:59
  18. avatar
    #16 Kaya 85

    By the way…how strong are Cornwall Hill and Southdowns….

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 20:42
  19. avatar
    #15 Kaya 85

    @Vleis: I think Midstream playing the GMPS (TM) would be a fantastic idea…

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 20:41
  20. avatar
    #14 BlouLou

    Its has been bugging me why a team that lost half their games can still be ranked in the top 10. (Yes, I am referring to Affies but they are not the only one) BHP has them somewhere around 13th, but 4 other ranker has them in the top 10 still. What is the bias built into the formulas that keeps teams ao high although they have lost so many times this season?

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 15:58
  21. avatar
    #13 Vleis

    @Kaya 85: @Asterix: If Midstream don’t enter the higher Noordvaal leagues, I suggest that they play all the Gauteng monastic private schools (GMPS). Midstream are at a similar level to the GMPS (perhaps a bit stronger at the mo); they’re also private and the GMPS have started playing each other twice due to losing fixtures v KES, Jeppe and Boys High….so a new school would be a welcome addition.

    A few years ago, Midstream played St Alban’s with a loss the first year and a win the next year, if I remember correctly. Whatever they decide, there is no point playing in their current rugby tier and hammering everyone by 60 to 90 points.

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 15:33
  22. avatar
    #12 Kaya 85

    @Asterix: Midstream by rights should be Valke Union, or even Lions…it’s technically Ekurhuleni

    ReplyReply
    15 June, 2023 at 14:30
  23. avatar
    #11 Maroon machine supporter

    @Asterix: Insightful, thanks and agreed, Oos-Moot vs Midstream would have been a very interesting match-up.

    ReplyReply
    14 June, 2023 at 21:57
  24. avatar
    #10 Asterix

    @Maroon machine supporter: Midstream have an exceptional good 1st team this year but are unfortanetly playing in about the 5th league of Noordvaal. On current form I believe they will beat Menlo 1st team but not Garsfontein or waterkloof, but we will never know as they dont play even close to the same schools so difficult to guess, This years 1st team of Oos-Moot and Midstream would have been a good game in my opinion, they used to play against each other before the change of the new Noordvaal cup.

    ReplyReply
    14 June, 2023 at 10:26
  25. avatar
    #9 Maroon machine supporter

    @Vleis Thanks, I have seen the big winning margins from Midstream and was wondering how they will do against a stronger school…

    ReplyReply
    14 June, 2023 at 05:47
  26. avatar
    #8 Vleis

    @Maroon machine supporter: Normally, Menlo would win, but this year would be interesting. I’d probably put my money on Midstream, as they have the confidence from an unbeaten season (I think) thus far, including huge thrashings of most schools that they’ve played – e.g. 92 to 0 v John Vorster, 68 to 0 v Wonderboom, etc.

    ReplyReply
    14 June, 2023 at 00:15
  27. avatar
    #7 gimmie

    BoishaaiPa and Nextgenxv without doubt the 2 most credible ranking systems…

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 23:53
  28. avatar
    #6 beet

    @Grant: For these 1st XV rankings they are pretty decent.

    I only found this out this year. The SASS ranking system is heavily relied on by school hockey, water polo, netball and soccer.

    “They now have about 17 tournaments that are held in hockey, netball, water polo and soccer that are all based on SASS rankings.( All the tournaments that have the word “Top Schools” or “super” 12), the schools all had to have the ranking formula audited before using it.

    However rugby is a different animal and the rugby community not so easy to please, …skin is going to be thick enough to handle the complaints.”

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 22:17
  29. avatar
    #5 Maroon machine supporter

    Vraag vir die manne van Pretoria…wie sal wen tussen Menlo en Midstream College as hulle nou moet speel?

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 22:09
  30. avatar
    #4 Grant

    @beet: SA Schoolsports are with respect out of touch with reality. Or without respect.

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 21:52
  31. avatar
    #3 beet

    @Kaya 85: Ruggas, BHP, SA SchoolSports and NextGenXV

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 21:50
  32. avatar
    #2 Grant

    As an Old Edwardian. Love this ranking 😂🤌🏻🥃🍷

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 21:19
  33. avatar
    #1 Kaya 85

    @ Beet
    Please remind us …. what are the other sites? R, B, N, S ?

    ReplyReply
    13 June, 2023 at 21:00

Leave a Reply