For one last time, here’s the exercise of combining the rankings of 5 websites including this one which makes use of the BHP formula driven system. The scoring method is simple 20 points for 1st place down to 1 point for 20th.
| RANK | SCHOOL | PTS | BHP | Site 1 | Site 2 | Site 3 | Site 4 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Paarl Gim | 98 | Paarl Gim | Affies | Paarl Gim | Affies | Paarl Gim |
| 2 | Affies | 96 | Affies | Paarl Gim | Affies | Paarl Gim | Outeniqua |
| 3 | Outeniqua | 88 | Grey College | Grey College | Outeniqua | Grey College | Affies |
| 4 | Grey College | 88 | Outeniqua | Outeniqua | Grey College | Outeniqua | Grey College |
| 5 | EG Jansen | 78 | EG Jansen | EG Jansen | Kearsney | EG Jansen | EG Jansen |
| 6 | Garsfontein | 68 | Garsfontein | Kearsney | HJS Paarl BH | Garsfontein | HJS Paarl BH |
| 7 | Nelspruit | 61 | Kearsney | Garsfontein | EG Jansen | Nelspruit | Nelspruit |
| 8 | HJS Paarl BH | 61 | HJS Paarl BH | Pretoria BH | Nelspruit | Waterkloof | Garsfontein |
| 9 | Waterkloof | 54 | Westville | Waterkloof | Waterkloof | HTS Middelburg | Waterkloof |
| 10 | Kearsney | 53 | Oakdale | Nelspruit | Garsfontein | Monnas | Oakdale |
| 11 | Monnas | 46 | Monnas | Jeppe | Monnas | HJS Paarl BH | Grey HS |
| 12 | Grey HS | 42 | Nelspruit | Westville | Grey HS | Grey HS | HTS Middelburg |
| 13 | HTS Middelburg | 35 | Grey HS | HJS Paarl BH | Oakdale | Kearsney | Monnas |
| 14 | Oakdale | 34 | Noord-Kaap | Monnas | HTS Middelburg | Glenwood | Kempton Park |
| 15 | Westville | 33 | Wynberg | Grey HS | Westville | Transvalia | Noord-Kaap |
| 16 | Pretoria BH | 21 | Waterkloof | St Andrews | Marlow | Kempton Park | Queens |
| 17 | Noord-Kaap | 16 | Pretoria BH | HTS Middelburg | Glenwood | Oakdale | Westville |
| 18 | Kempton Park | 12 | HTS Middelburg | Transvalia | Pretoria BH | Noord-Kaap | St Andrews |
| 19 | Glenwood | 12 | Drostdy | Queens | Wynberg | Westville | Marlow |
| 20 | Jeppe | 10 | Glenwood | Menlopark | Queens | Pretoria BH | Wynberg |
| 21 | Wynberg | 9 | Queens | Wynberg | Centurion | ||
| 22 | Transvalia | 9 | Selborne | Hilton | Menlopark | ||
| 23 | Queens | 8 | Paul Roos | Marlow | Jeppe | ||
| 24 | St Andrews | 8 | St Andrews | Oakdale | Queens | ||
| 25 | Marlow | 7 | Menlopark | Noord-Kaap | Paul Roos | ||
| 26 | Drostdy | 2 | Marlow | Centurion | Wynberg | ||
| 27 | Menlopark | 1 | SACS | Kempton Park | Drostdy | ||
| 28 | Centurion | 1 | Centurion | Michaelhouse | Selborne | ||
| 29 | Paul Roos | 0 | Jeppe | Voortrekker (Beth) | Hilton | ||
| 30 | Selborne | 0 | Rondebosch | Nico Malan | Louis Botha |
Obvious Outliers with the emphasis on obvious!
BHP – Kempton Park not on the list despite playing in the Beeld final.
Site 1 – Pretoria Boys High too high in 8th and HJS Paarl too low in 13th
Site 2 – Also no Kempton Park on the list and Kearsney too high
Site 4 – Outeniqua and Affies should switch
@EG Ouer: well done site 2 , die enigste korrekte rankings
@Beet: Weet nie wie site 2 is nie maar hulle is duidelik nie in Suid Afrika nie. Kearsney en HJS Paarl bo EG Jansen. Moet maar net giggel daaroor.
Beet unable to locate the rankings on the internet for site 2 and 3? If site 3 is R15 it is not the latest? Site 2 HSRW?
It’s very easy to see which rankings list ranks based on reputation, and which list goes on a formula. In my opinion, on no list should St Andrews be above Queens for example.
Combined ranking is spot on! Finally the law of averages prevails! :-)